UK Accounting Authority Fines Audit Firms PwC & KPMG $3.6 Million & Reprimanded for Audit of Eddie Stobart Logistics, Partners from PwC & KPMG also Fined & Reprimanded
29th June 2023 | Hong Kong
The UK Accounting Authority (United Kingdom, Financial Reporting Council, FRC) has fined audit firms PwC & KPMG a total of $3.6 million (£2.8 million) & reprimanded for audit of Eddie Stobart Logistics, with partners from PwC & KPMG also fined & reprimanded. PwC: A financial sanction of £3.5 million adjusted for the mitigating factor of exceptional cooperation and further discounted for admissions and early disposal to £1,990,625. PwC Audit Engagement Partner Philip Storer: A financial sanction of £90,000 adjusted for the mitigating factor of exceptional cooperation and further discounted for admissions and early disposal to £51,187.50. KPMG: A financial sanction of £1.35 million, discounted for admissions and early disposal to £877,500. KPMG’s poor disciplinary record was noted as an aggravating factor. KPMG Statutory Auditor and Audit Engagement Partner Nicola Quayle: A financial sanction of £70,000 discounted for admissions and early disposal to £45,500. Notable aggravating factors were Ms Quayle’s seniority at the point of signing the audit report and past disciplinary record. See below for UK Financial Reporting Council statement.
“ UK Accounting Authority Fines Audit Firms PwC & KPMG $3.6 Million & Reprimanded for Audit of Eddie Stobart Logistics, Partners from PwC & KPMG also Fined & Reprimanded “
UK Accounting Authority Fines Audit Firms PwC & KPMG $3.6 Million & Reprimanded for Audit of Eddie Stobart Logistics
1) Sanctions against PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP and audit partner
29th June 2023 – The Executive Counsel of the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has issued a Final Settlement Decision Notice under the Audit Enforcement Procedure and imposed sanctions against PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP and Philip Storer, Audit Engagement Partner, in relation to the statutory audit of the financial statements of Eddie Stobart Logistics plc (ESL) for the financial year ended 30 November 2018.
The sanctions are:
Against PwC:
- A financial sanction of £3.5 million adjusted for the mitigating factor of exceptional cooperation and further discounted for admissions and early disposal to £1,990,625.
- Non-financial sanctions, comprising:
- a Severe Reprimand;
- a declaration that the 2018 audit report did not satisfy the Relevant Requirements; and
- an order requiring PwC to take specified actions to prevent the occurrence of the contravention.
Against Mr Storer:
- A financial sanction of £90,000 adjusted for the mitigating factor of exceptional cooperation and further discounted for admissions and early disposal to £51,187.50.
- Non-financial sanctions, comprising:
- a Severe Reprimand; and
- a declaration that the 2018 audit report did not satisfy the Relevant Requirements.
ESL, a company operating in the supply chain, transport and logistics business, was listed on the Alternative Investment Market. KPMG performed the 2017 audit and resigned as auditor in 2018, because of a breakdown in their relationship with ESL’s management, following difficulties in obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence. PwC were subsequently appointed for the 2018 audit. In July 2019, ESL announced that a review had been conducted into its prior year financial statements. Following this review, in 2020, ESL disclosed significant prior year accounting adjustments to the 2018 financial year. PwC and Mr Storer breached Relevant Requirements in some of the areas which were subject to prior year adjustments.
In summary, the auditors’ admitted failings related to the audit work carried out on:
- the property transactions entered into by ESL, and the disclosure in the financial statements regarding those transactions. These transactions had a significant effect on ESL’s financial performance, and without the profit generated from them, ESL would have been in a loss-making position;
- first year audit procedures;
- dilapidations;
- accounting for a subsidiary company; and
- property lease accruals.
There were numerous serious failures in relation to the audit work on ESL’s property transactions, including a failure to identify revenue recognition on those transactions as a significant risk of material misstatement; failing to carry out a formal consultation on the technical aspects of accounting for these transactions; a lack of challenge of management’s selection of accounting policy; and a lack of professional judgement in their work on the transactions. Furthermore, the disclosures in the financial statements failed to adequately explain the impact of the property transactions on ESL’s financial performance. PwC and Mr Storer assisted in the investigation by making comprehensive early admissions (including admissions relating to matters which were not in the communicated scope of the investigation), and this has been recognised in the discount to the financial sanction of 12.5% (in addition to the 35% reduction for early settlement) to reflect exceptional cooperation as a mitigating factor.
Claudia Mortimore, FRC Deputy Executive Counsel: ““There were numerous, serious and pervasive failings in this audit. The case highlights the importance of, firstly, the auditor’s work in ensuring that disclosures in financial statements enable users to understand the impact of particular transactions on the entity’s financial performance, and, secondly, auditors undertaking formal consultation during the course of the engagement where appropriate. The Respondents’ exceptional cooperation in the investigation has been recognised in the discount to the financial sanction.”
2) Sanctions against KPMG LLP and audit partner
29th June 2023 -The Executive Counsel of the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has issued a Final Settlement Decision Notice under the Audit Enforcement Procedure and imposed sanctions against KPMG LLP and Nicola Quayle, a former partner of KPMG who was the Statutory Auditor and Audit Engagement Partner, in relation to the statutory audit of the financial statements of Eddie Stobart Logistics plc (ESL) for the financial year ended 30 November 2017.
The sanctions are:
Against KPMG:
- A financial sanction of £1.35 million, discounted for admissions and early disposal to £877,500. KPMG’s poor disciplinary record was noted as an aggravating factor;
- Non-financial sanctions, comprising:
- a Severe Reprimand;
- a declaration that the 2017 audit report did not satisfy the Relevant Requirements; and
- an order requiring KPMG to take specified actions to prevent the re-occurrence of the contravention.
Against Ms Quayle:
- A financial sanction of £70,000 discounted for admissions and early disposal to £45,500. Notable aggravating factors were Ms Quayle’s seniority at the point of signing the audit report and past disciplinary record;
- Non-financial sanctions, comprising:
- a Severe Reprimand; and
- a declaration that the 2017 audit report did not satisfy the Relevant Requirements.
Ms Quayle ceased performing Statutory Audits in 2020 and no longer holds a practising certificate. She has provided an undertaking that she will not carry out Statutory Audits or sign Statutory Audit reports in the future.
ESL, a company operating in the supply chain, transport and logistics business, was listed on the Alternative Investment Market. KPMG performed the 2017 audit and resigned as auditor in 2018, because of a breakdown in their relationship with ESL’s management, following difficulties in obtaining sufficient appropriate audit evidence.
In July 2019, ESL announced that a review had been conducted into its prior year financial statements. Following this review, in 2020, ESL disclosed significant prior year accounting adjustments to the 2017 financial year. KPMG and Ms Quayle breached Relevant Requirements in some of the areas which were subject to prior year adjustments.
Broadly, the admitted failings related to the audit work carried out on:
- property transactions entered into by ESL, and the disclosure in the financial statements regarding those transactions. These transactions had a significant effect on ESL’s financial performance, and without the profit generated from them, ESL would have been in a loss-making position;
- dilapidations; and
- accounting for a subsidiary company.
In respect of the property transactions, the auditors failed to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence of services provided by ESL in those transactions to allow revenue to be ascribed to the provision of those services and recognised up-front in the financial year. Further, the disclosures in the financial statements relating to the property transactions did not adequately explain the impact of those transactions on ESL’s financial performance. The failings were serious but not pervasive.
Claudia Mortimore, Deputy Executive Counsel: “There were some serious failings admitted in this case; although they were not pervasive throughout the audit. The case highlights the importance of, firstly, the auditor’s work in ensuring that disclosures in financial statements enable users to understand the impact of particular transactions on the entity’s financial performance; and secondly, ensuring that advice received in technical consultations is effectively implemented.”
Sign Up / Register
Caproasia Users
- Manage $20 million to $3 billion of assets
- Invest $3 million to $300 million
- Advise institutions, billionaires, UHNWs & HNWs
Caproasia Platforms | 11,000 Investors & Advisors
- Caproasia.com
- Caproasia Access
- Caproasia Events
- The Financial Centre | Find Services
- Membership
- Family Office Circle
- Professional Investor Circle
- Investor Relations Network
Monthly Roundtable & Networking
Family Office Programs
The 2024 Investment Day
- March 2024 - Hong Kong
- March 2024 - Singapore
- July 2024 - Hong Kong
- July 2024 - Singapore
- Sept 2024 - Hong Kong
- Sept 2024 - Singapore
- Oct 2024 - Hong Kong
- Nov 2024 - Singapore
- Visit: The Investment Day | Register: Click here
Caproasia Summits
- The Institutional Investor Summit
- The Investment / Alternatives Summit
- The Private Wealth Summit
- The Family Office Summit
- The CEO & Entrepreneur Summit
- The Capital Markets Summit
- The ESG / Sustainable Investment Summit
