Citigroup Fat-Finger Trader Received 711 Warnings But Approved the Orders on 2nd May 2022 after Keying to Sell 58 Million Quantity Instead of $58 Million & Creating $444 Billion Sell Orders in 349 Stocks in 13 Countries with $1.4 Billion Sold, Purpose of Trade is to Hedge Citigroup Exposure to MSCI World Index, Automated Tool to Build Sell Orders of Stocks Was Not Available on the Day so Trader Had to Build the Basket of Stocks Manually, Monitoring of the Traders by Citigroup Algorithmic Service Desk Transferred to Electronic Execution Desk as Staff was on Leave, Citigroup Lost $48 Million in Error, Trader Had Since Left Citigroup
23rd May 2024 | Hong Kong
Citigroup fat-finger trader had received 711 warnings but approved the orders on 2nd May 2022 after keying to sell 58 million quantity instead of $58 million, and creating $444 billion of sell orders in 349 stocks in 13 countries with $1.4 billion sold. The purpose of the trade is to hedge Citigroup exposure to the MSCI World Index. An automated tool to build the sell orders of stocks was not available on the day so the trader had to build the basket of stocks manually. Monitoring of the trades by Citigroup Algorithmic Service Desk was transferred to the Electronic Execution Desk as a staff was on leave. Citigroup lost $48 million in the error, and the trader had since left Citigroup. In 2024 May, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) & Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) have fined Citigroup a total of $79 million (£61.6 million – £27.7 million & £33.8 million) for a European fat-finger equity trade error in 2022 with $1.4 billion accidentally sold and triggering a European market 8% sell-off in minutes. In 2022 May, the Citigroup trader had created a $444 billion trade order instead of a $58 million order. Although Citigroup controls blocked $255 billion of trades, but $189 billion of orders were sent to Citigroup trading algorithm, with $1.4 billion equities sold before the trader cancelled the order. UK FCA (22/5/24): ”The FCA has fined Citigroup Global Markets Limited (CGML) £27,766,200. Failures in the firm’s systems and controls led to US$1.4bn of equities being sold in European markets when they should not have been. On 2 May 2022, a CGML trader had intended to sell a basket of equities to the value of US$58m. The trader made an inputting error while entering the basket in an order management system. This resulted in a basket to the value of US$444bn being created. CGML controls blocked US$255bn of the basket progressing, but not the remaining US$189bn which was sent to a trading algorithm. The algorithm selected was designed to place portions of this total order to be sold in the market over the rest of the day. In total US$1.4bn of equities were sold across European exchanges, before the trader cancelled the order. This coincided with a material short-term drop in some European indices which lasted a few minutes. While parts of CGML’s trading control framework operated as CGML expected, some primary controls were absent or deficient. In particular, there was no hard block that would have rejected this large erroneous basket of equities in its entirety and prevented any of it reaching the market. Due to poor design, the trader was also able to manually override a pop-up alert, without being required to scroll down and read all the alerts within it. The firm’s real-time monitoring was ineffective, which meant that it was too slow to escalate internal alerts about the erroneous trades. CGML did not dispute the FCA’s findings and agreed to settle, which means it has qualified for a 30% discount. Without this discount, the amount of financial penalty imposed by the FCA would have been £39,666,000. On 22 May 2024, the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) also imposed a financial penalty of £33,880,000 on CGML following its own investigation into related matters.” See below for more info:
“ Citigroup Fat-Finger Trader Received 711 Warnings But Approved the Orders on 2nd May 2022 after Keying to Sell 58 Million Quantity Instead of $58 Million & Creating $444 Billion Sell Orders in 349 Stocks in 13 Countries with $1.4 Billion Sold, Purpose of Trade is to Hedge Citigroup Exposure to MSCI World Index, Automated Tool to Build Sell Orders of Stocks Was Not Available on the Day so Trader Had to Build the Basket of Stocks Manually, Monitoring of the Traders by Citigroup Algorithmic Service Desk Transferred to Electronic Execution Desk as Staff was on Leave, Citigroup Lost $48 Million in Error, Trader Had Since Left Citigroup “
UK Regulators Fine Citigroup $79 Million for European Fat-Finger Equity Trade Error in 2022 with $1.4 Billion Accidentally Sold & Triggering European Market 8% Sell-off in Minutes, Trader Created a $444 Billion Trade Order Instead of $58 Million Order, Citigroup Controls Blocked $255 Billion But $189 Billion Sent to Trading Algorithm, $1.4 Billion Equities Were Sold Before Trader Cancelled the Order
22nd May 2024 – The UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) & Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) have fined Citigroup a total of $79 million (£61.6 million – £27.7 million & £33.8 million) for a European fat-finger equity trade error in 2022 with $1.4 billion accidentally sold and triggering a European market 8% sell-off in minutes. In 2022 May, the Citigroup trader had created a $444 billion trade order instead of a $58 million order. Although Citigroup controls blocked $255 billion of trades, but $189 billion of orders were sent to Citigroup trading algorithm, with $1.4 billion equities sold before the trader cancelled the order. UK FCA (22/5/24): ”The FCA has fined Citigroup Global Markets Limited (CGML) £27,766,200. Failures in the firm’s systems and controls led to US$1.4bn of equities being sold in European markets when they should not have been. On 2 May 2022, a CGML trader had intended to sell a basket of equities to the value of US$58m. The trader made an inputting error while entering the basket in an order management system. This resulted in a basket to the value of US$444bn being created. CGML controls blocked US$255bn of the basket progressing, but not the remaining US$189bn which was sent to a trading algorithm. The algorithm selected was designed to place portions of this total order to be sold in the market over the rest of the day. In total US$1.4bn of equities were sold across European exchanges, before the trader cancelled the order. This coincided with a material short-term drop in some European indices which lasted a few minutes. While parts of CGML’s trading control framework operated as CGML expected, some primary controls were absent or deficient. In particular, there was no hard block that would have rejected this large erroneous basket of equities in its entirety and prevented any of it reaching the market. Due to poor design, the trader was also able to manually override a pop-up alert, without being required to scroll down and read all the alerts within it. The firm’s real-time monitoring was ineffective, which meant that it was too slow to escalate internal alerts about the erroneous trades. CGML did not dispute the FCA’s findings and agreed to settle, which means it has qualified for a 30% discount. Without this discount, the amount of financial penalty imposed by the FCA would have been £39,666,000. On 22 May 2024, the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) also imposed a financial penalty of £33,880,000 on CGML following its own investigation into related matters.” See below for more info:
Steve Smart, Joint Executive Director Of Enforcement And Market Oversight at The FCA: “The FCA expects firms engaged in trading activities, including those using algorithmic trading, to have effective systems and controls in place to stop errors like this occurring. These failings led to over a billion pounds of erroneous orders being executed and risked creating a disorderly market. We expect firms to look at their own controls and ensure that they are appropriate given the speed and complexity of financial markets.”
Notes
- Read the FCA’s Final Notice to CGML.
- Read the PRA’s Final Notice to CGML.
- The FCA found that CGML breached the following during the relevant period:
- Principle 2 of the FCA Handbook (requires a firm to conduct its business with due skill, care, and diligence)
- Principle 3 of the FCA Handbook (requires a firm to take reasonable care to organise and control its affairs responsibly and effectively, with adequate risk management systems)
- Rule 7A.3.2 of the Market Conduct part of the FCA’s handbook known as MAR (requires firms that engage in algorithmic trading to have in place effective systems and controls, suitable to the business it operates)
- CGML is regulated by the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) for prudential purposes and by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) for conduct matters.
- Read the FCA’s approach to enforcement.
- Read the FCA enforcement information guide.
- Read the PRA’s statutory supervisory powers.
- Read the PRA’s approach to enforcement.
Citigroup Fat-Finger Trade Error May Cost $50 Million in Losses, An Extra Zero Triggered European Market 8% Sell-off in Minutes
3rd June 2022 – Citigroup fat-finger trade error may cost the American bank more than $50 million in trading losses, with an extra zero keyed in by a Citi trader causing a flash crash in Europe, with Swedish stocks dropping 8% in minutes (Swedish benchmark: Stockholm OMX 30 drops 7.9%) in May 2022 (2/5/22) and triggering further sell-off in Germany, France, Norway & Denmark. Citi: “One of our traders made an error when inputting a transaction. Within minutes, we identified the error and corrected it.” Nasdaq Stockholm: ”Nasdaq is continuously investigating all market movements on our market places, and we have done the same in this situation. The reason for the drop was a sell event by a market participant. We have not identified any disturbances in Nasdaq’s systems. Nasdaq has not seen any reason to cancel trades that were made during this event.”
Sign Up / Register
Caproasia Users
- Manage $20 million to $3 billion of assets
- Invest $3 million to $300 million
- Advise institutions, billionaires, UHNWs & HNWs
Caproasia Platforms | 11,000 Investors & Advisors
- Caproasia.com
- Caproasia Access
- Caproasia Events
- The Financial Centre | Find Services
- Membership
- Family Office Circle
- Professional Investor Circle
- Investor Relations Network
Monthly Roundtable & Networking
Family Office Programs
The 2024 Investment Day
- March 2024 - Hong Kong
- March 2024 - Singapore
- July 2024 - Hong Kong
- July 2024 - Singapore
- Sept 2024 - Hong Kong
- Sept 2024 - Singapore
- Oct 2024 - Hong Kong
- Nov 2024 - Singapore
- Visit: The Investment Day | Register: Click here
Caproasia Summits
- The Institutional Investor Summit
- The Investment / Alternatives Summit
- The Private Wealth Summit
- The Family Office Summit
- The CEO & Entrepreneur Summit
- The Capital Markets Summit
- The ESG / Sustainable Investment Summit
